It is very possible when Darlie was wetting the towels if they were big towels and they drapped down infront of the sink cupboards then could have rubbed against the front of the kitchen sink cupboards and this is why it looked like an attempted clean up. Kudos to you JustinCase Great article. It is my understanding that recent testing of the night shirt revealed an unknown DNA profile. What do you remember Sergeant Walling telling either of the Routiers? As anyone who is familiar with this case already knows, the original transcripts contained over 33,000 errors. I don't see where either Darren or Darlie ever said that. Even the state's expert witnesses conceded that an intruder may not necessarily have tracked blood while making his exit. Did Darlie get a fair trial? One also must wonder if there was actual evidence of an intruder, did it conveniently disappear? So many questions too many coincidences. There is no tone, no inflection, no facial expressions or body language. Alan Brantley, a Special Agent with the FBI's Behavioral Science Unit, testified that the force of the wounds on the children indicated extreme rage. IMO. Her ex-husband still believes that she's innocent. HubPages is a registered trademark of The Arena Platform, Inc. Other product and company names shown may be trademarks of their respective owners. The defense also brought up the sock found on the street containing traces of Devon and Damons blood, but the prosecutors claimed that it was a part of her ruse as well. Untouchable is the horrifying story of Harvey Weinsteins abuse of power, told by the women who suffered physical and mental abuse caused at his hand. When it came time for this family to lay the boys to rest, it was all about honoring them, their lives, and the things that made them happy. Some people theorize that the bruising was a result of Devon kicking at her while she was stabbing him, since he did show signs of defensive injuries. Did Darlie do it? Every time he would receive a mugshot, he would send it to Karl, who did not know Arkansas's real name and was not familiar with the man he had been arguing with. A liar already has their story prepared in their mind. In this article, we will unravel Darlie Routier's net worth and her history. Listen Now Episode Info Darlie Routier with Damon (left) and Devon (right). Dr. Phil is a non-factor and is about as useful as tits on a bull. I love how the non supporters always say Darin was the primary suspect at first. This fingerprint did not match one single person who was known to be in the house that night; it did not belong to any of the Routiers, nor did it match any of the police officers or paramedics (all were printed to rule them out). JustinCase976 (author) on December 14, 2019: I honestly haven't seen any evidence that this housekeeper had anything to do with what happened. Because they thought the house was empty, and were taken by surprise. If they do, my bet is that is that someone is going to end up taking a deal from prosecutors. The neighborhood children called it "The Nintendo House" because of the elaborate game room made just for kids. I've looked, believe me. Devon scrambles to his feet and starts for the hallway. Darin and Darlie purchased the house toward the end of 1992 and moved in at the beginning of 1993. Trollslayer is probably Bryan st john or Slemmons or Arthur. The sock had drops of Devon's and Damon's blood on it, but none of Darlie's blood. His reply cannot be heard; he may have answered non-verbally with a nod, but he's in the room with Darlie when she asks the question. Under Toby Shook's brutal cross-examination, Darlie became non-responsive, argumentative, and even downright angry. The same reasoning applies to Darlie's interchanging usage of the pronouns "he" and "they." In 2017, the small town of Delphi, Indiana, was torn apart by the brutal killing of two young girls. She picked it up and placed it on the counter before realizing that she and her children were hurt and called 911. I hold firmly to the belief that one of the intruders rounded a corner and walked right into the wine rack, causing the glass to break on impact while it was still in the holder. The location of the vacuum cleaner was another detail that caused investigators to suspect staging. I interpret that as another sign of innocence; it's not definitive, but I doubt a guilty person would have taken that chance. and like the article you wrote about the case Speaking of Psychics . So what about the future, lets say hypothetically, Darlie free. Darlie picked up the knife without thinking about it and headed back to the family room where she and her young sons had fallen asleep. How do you know if the bedroom door was closed with the dog in there? He's also the one who arranged Darin's polygraph test. There is no logic to support the theory of her planting that sock, even if she is the killer. There was a brief mention of it when Darlie was on the witness stand, but the prosecution objected on the grounds of hearsay. What I do fault him for is his perjury and outright character assassination of Darlie during his testimony. May 11, 2019 24 Months That Changed the World Share a story idea with ABC News Live Did you have a conversation with Mrs. Routier? After 22 years, Darlie Routier remains on death row for son's murder: Part 11 Defense investigators are still working to prove she was not involved in her sons' deaths. There was no exact match to any prints that are in the systemincluding Darlie Routier's. 20 years later, doubt still remains. DeHart was a hacktivist with a connection to the hacker group, Anonymous. Nothing new in the DNA. Wonder what they've been up to all of this time. No, he was referring to someone else entirely. At the time of his death, Devon weighed 46 lbs. Darlie's eldest son, Devon, had already died from four knife wounds. It is not unlike being injured and knocked out during a car accident. In a move that would turn out to be an epic fail, defense attorney Doug Mulder used this as an excuse to blast the detectives and insinuate to the jury that they had broken the law with their graveyard surveillance. Socialism, or in this case, The Big Scary S Word, has been a taboo word in American culture for decades. A. I assumed it was two to three or four minutes, somewhere in that area. How did that come to be? is a documentary set out to bring justice to Bill Finger, the uncredited creator of, In 2009, Matt DeHart was persecuted by the American government for possessing child pornography, but DeHart claims he was framed, . I wish you could say all the things too!!!! Okay. If she was just seeking attention, it would make more sense to call the police the very next day upon hearing about the murders. It may go a long way with regard to getting her a new trial, but even that is not a given. There were millions of dollars worth of investments and development tied up in this desirable little crime-free community. Some of her followers think shes a miracle worker, others see right through her. What started as a viral YouTube video quickly turned an entire community inside out. Two of these associates were a married couple identified in the book as "Dwayne" and "Karen." In early 1998, Karl was in jail reading The New Yorker magazine when he came upon an article about the impending execution of Karla Faye Tucker. Check out these must-watch. tells Nawabis story through animation and voiceovers to uncover the painful truth that could set back everything hes worked so hard to achieve in his new life. Reality #1. Victorias Secret: Angels and Demons is a Hulu Original documentary uncovering the hidden dark side of VSs light pink illusion that led to the retail giants downfall. That was their habit for the four years that they had Domain, and there is no reason to believe that they deviated from that habit on the night in question. Watch on your TV, laptop, phone, or tablet. Although the medical examiner found this to be highly suspicious, in the end, his death was classified as a suicide. It has always amused me that Guilters so readily dismiss Rickels as a liar or a hysterical little woman who imagined the whole incident because she was watching a horror flick. The long-unsolved case of Patricia Kalitzke and Duane Bogle is believed to be the oldest cold case in the country solved through the breakthrough technology. We also have to wonder what was stricken from the actual record, but still made it to the ears of the jury. If she was laying on the couch, and a man with a knife mounted her, the first thing anyone would do would be to raise their arms up defensively, thus accounting for the black-and-blue bruising up and down her arms. This documentary delves deep into the history of socialism and the modern socialist movement through interviews with prominent political figures including Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Is youryou know, sometimes I'll set my clock a little bit fast just so that hopefully I get where I'm supposed to be on time. Much has been made of a diary entry in Darlie's journal dated May 3, 1996, a little over a month before the murders. Answer: According to my research, witness perjury alone would not be enough to overturn the conviction. It made them want someone to be punished and added a degree of hostility toward Darlie in their testimony. You can also stream it on FuboTV (free trial), Sling or Hulu + Live TV. Conversations with Robert Fratta September 2, 2013 44min TV-14 Subtitles presents the world with a behind the scenes look at a ground-breaking and controversial science experiment that happened 31 years ago. Darlie Lynn Peck Routier (born January 4, 1970) is an American woman from Rowlett, Texas, who was convicted and sentenced to death for the murder of her five-year-old son Damon in 1996. Next up is an expert who was never called to testify: Dr. Kenneth Dekleva, the state's own forensic psychiatrist. ", At the time, Karl had been in jail for months and knew nothing of the Rowlett murders. But just because it's my theory doesn't mean it's right; you might have nailed it. CODIS, or Combined DNA Index System, is a little more complex. I can understand her anger and frustration at yet another violation of privacy. Although the crime scene photos show that there was blood all over the house, what they don't realize is that the blood was not present at the moment the intruder left. Why would she deliberately torture herself by having to hear those soul-crushing words again? What if the baby woke up and Darin had to come down and warm up a bottle? I can think of at least two other alternative possibilities. Directed by Bing Liu, Minding the Gap is an Oscar-nominated documentary that follows three young men who bond over skateboarding to escape their turbulent home lives in the Rust Belt of America. He never submitted a report, becauseyou guessed ithe was instructed not to. Those who do not. I believe he took that chance just as Waddell was pulling up. Do you set yours rightI bet you set yours right on the money, don't you? Its results, though, are currently pending, from what we can tell. According to Jovell, I believe she said the accomplice was a friend of her daughter's and that they took the car to a farm in Oklahoma to hide it. Okay. After putting Darlie in jail with bail set at $1 million, the state of Texas placed baby Drake in a foster home in 1996. He did not have a conversation with her; she was already at the hospital when he got to the house. If the vacuum was laying on the floor when these two police officers arrived, they would have seen it at first glance. What was he a suspect for, a whole 2 hours? That's funny, Laurie! Q. Besides the trouble was downstairs,not upstairs. Patterson would have been forced to admit in open court that no such confession had been made, at which point Mulder should have smiled like a shark, said "Thank you, no further questions" and sat down like the boss he was supposed to be. Take a harrowing yet healing look back at. Whatever it is, it must be favorable for Darlie. What kind of mother has bleached blonde hair and $5,000 breast implants? From what Karen remembers hearing from Dwayne upon their return, the men had broken into a house that was supposed to be empty and "f***ed some people up. 5) Yes, the knife came from her house. He knew only what the police had told him. Police inspected those and found no blood. On June 6th, 1996, someone brutally murdered two little boys and got away with it. of the pandemica testament to the power of bravery and human connection. The officer, of course, is Matt Walling. Feet US Of Clay Poster (1924) US Insert Movie Clay Poster ! I believe it ALL happened. Menu Cron certainly had an impressive resume and over 30 years of experience, but sometimes this can work against a person. Top Deals This Week: Save on Paramount+, Showtime, HBO Max, Fire TV, and Roku, Puss in Boots: The Last Wish Is Now Available to Stream on Amazon Prime Video, Amazon Slashed Prices on all Sorts of Fire TV Stick Models, Amazon Fire Tablets on Sale: Save up to 45%, The Ultimate Guide to What to Watch on Netflix, Prime Video, Hulu, HBO Max, and More in March 2023, Amazon Prime Video's New Shows and Movies in March, 8 Shows Like The Last of Us to Watch While You Wait for the Next Episode, 9 Shows Like Ginny & Georgia to Watch After You Finish Season 2, 12 Intense Thriller Shows and Movies to Watch If You Like Squid Game, 9 Shows Like Fringe to Watch If You Like Fringe, Here's When Yellowstone Will Return for Season 5 Part 2, Pedro Pascal Has an Update for Last of Us Season 2 Filming, Everything to Know About The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 2, Amazon Exec Teases a Release Date for Reacher Season 2, Everything You Need to Know About Euphoria Season 3. In the book, Cruz describes how Darlie received a letter in 1998 from an inmate at another facility. Your dad loves you all very much and I know in my heart he will take care of my babies. I believe his shady business deals were the reason this happened, and he knew it, and did everything in his power to keep it from coming back on him. I have to admit though, I loved the judge from that movie. JustinCase976 (author) on February 29, 2020: I do remember that Darlie said they had a psychic come to the house to do a reading. See Darlie Routier full list of movies and tv shows from their career. Darlie Lynn Peck Routier is an American-born woman originally from Rowlett, Texas. If that is the case, I urge you to contact the authorities with everything you know. What Darlie initially relayed to the police, her family, and the media was most likely disjointed fragments of memories assembled to the best of her ability. Ive never had a mental illness, she admitted in 2020, referring to what happened at her trial. The prosecution successfully appealed to the conservative jurors' subconscious prejudices by usage of the above-mentioned emotional trifecta. Adding: "What mother, whose children are dead or dying, would even be thinking about fingerprints on a weapon if she's innocent?". What's wrong with this woman? The Arena Media Brands, LLC and respective content providers to this website may receive compensation for some links to products and services on this website. He testified that he saw Darin and Officer Waddell together in the yard, and saw them go into the house together. Out of all the things that non-supporters say, that takes the cake as the stupidest thing I've ever heard. Seeing those bloody, butchered children invoked anger in the nurses, most of whom were women. Ambitious journalist Audrey Harper heads to Hope Cove to write an . Wouldnt a new investigation begin? Darlie replied with the only thing she could possibly have saidthat she had already touched it when she picked it up. He even left a huge clue to his identity by cutting the screen in the shape of his first initial. Darlie suddenly and inexplicably snapped in the middle of the night. When Darlie mentioned the knife to Waddell, the dispatcher immediately instructed her not to touch it. There is an innocent white woman going down for all this and it just sickens me. They break into what they think is an empty house and come upon the family room. All right. The ambulance that was directly in front of Walling parked along a curve on Eagle Drive, across from the Routier's house and directly underneath where Gorsuch was standing. At the time, Darlie had two different private investigators working on the case and feeding her (sometimes conflicting) information. Who has time to change when your kids are stabbed to death and your wife could die too? She refused. It can be reasonably assumed that his reply is affirmative, since she immediately becomes even more hysterical and screams, "Oh my God!". The prosecution held a mock trial prior to the nurses testifying, a bit of a dress rehearsal, you might say. Officer Waddell was not actually dispatched to Eagle Drive; he just happened to be nearby when the call came in over the radio. Kriti Mehrotra. In 2013, Werner Herzog made a documentary about the Routier case called On Death Row. If anyone ever looks at it all they'll see is "did you really think I'd be dumb enough to write anything personal? This whole case reeks of corruption! Q. A Darlie Routier Documentary - YouTube 0:00 / 10:38 A Darlie Routier Documentary GhoulishGal 26.6K subscribers 2.5K views 4 years ago Darlie seemed to have it all. I honestly have no idea. Please do not try to tell me that the print was Damon's; the DNA blood map clearly shows that the child went nowhere near the glass table where that print was located. I do agree with you that he was involved along with several associates. He never notified the dispatcher that he was on the scene; therefore, the dispatcher had no idea that a police officer was in the house and did not realize that Darlie was speaking to him. Ultimately, on February 1, 1997, Darlie was convicted for the murder of her 5-year-old son, Damon. These maggots do not know the facts of the case like me and you. Darlie, who doesn't know what to do, is simply doing as she has been instructed. However, Officer David Mayne, who was responsible for the collection of evidence at the crime scene, used the phrase "I'm not for sure" 48 times during his cross-examination, and "I don't recall" exactly 25 times, for a whopping total of 73 times. That plan was still in place on the night of the murders, although it certainly raises the possibility that the men got the date wrong and were counting on the house being empty. This time, one of them had what appeared to be a screwdriver or knife. My belief is that Darlie is the one who grabbed the butcher knife, to fight the man off, and he got it away from her. Okay. I also think she resented the fact that in Poland, she was a Registered Nurse, while in America, she was reduced to folding someone else's laundry for $50. Darlie would have known that he gets home around two in the morning, and if she did plant the sock, it had to be before the 911 call came in at 2:31. is a documentary that chronicles the unbelievable dark story behind the rise and fall of the once iconic brand. This is the shocking story of Jasmine Richardson, a 12-year-old girl who met an older man, Jeremy Steinke, and ended up murdering her entire family. Darlie was given the death penalty for these murders. is the cornerstone of childhood nostalgia. They found DNA from a black male on the sock found in the ally. They also stated that had Darlie been acquitted of Damon's murder, they could have then charged her with Devon's murder, doubling their chances of a convictionhmmm, perhaps their case was not as strong as they would like us to believe? Waddell testified that when he first pulled up to the house, he saw a man (Darin Routier) coming out of the front door into the yard. The notorious killer, who is one of the longest serving death row inmates in the USA, claims she loves. I see what you're saying, Curious George. So which one is true? She grabbed a butcher knife and just started stabbing her kids in a rage. Q. Darin knew if Darlie left him he would be exposed for everything. I live in the real world and I know all too well that these things happen; I just don't believe that it happened in the case of Darlie Routier. Discover never-before-seen in-depth interviews with McCartney where he discusses creation and inspiration for his music that became the soundtrack of our generation. Sucker!". Apart from marking her as greedy and uncaring, they also highlighted that she could not give a clear description of the intruder, and nothing was stolen from her home, raising the question of if he really existed. Darlie Routier is a American woman from Texas. When you have a baby under a year old that sleeps in the same room with you, you never quite slip into that deep, restful sleep. You don't think its at all suspicious how her story kept changing? 'Darlie Routier' the 20/20 Documentary Event Special airs Tonight at 9/8c on ABC A mother on death row for the unthinkable. The defense wanted to put Mr. Harrell on the stand to bring this discrepancy to the attention of the jury. Had Bevel been on the other side of the case, I firmly believe Tolle would have ruled differently. I've said it before, and I'll say it again: not even the most hardened criminals would go around talking about stabbing little kids if it never happened. When you think of the creator of Batman, you probably think of Bob Kane. Look at the floor plan of the Routier's first floor to get a better idea of where they were positioned. From Britney Spears conservatorship and Janet Jacksons Super Bowl scandal to social media influencers and even the popularity of vapingthis documentary series covers it all. Darlie later told officers that shed fallen asleep while watching television on the couch and had woken up only to find a long-haired man, wearing a baseball cap, t-shirt, and jeans, in her living room. I tried to contact Darlie's lawyer, her mother, her friends anyone who might look and listen and I couldn't get anywhere. Darin Routier Husband of Darlie Routier and father of their three sons. The wheels of justice turn excruciatingly slowly, and even slower in the state of Texas. Read all Director Ryan Kester Writers Kinsey Jamison Ryan Kester She is not concerned about her own prints being on that knife; it's her knife, from her own kitchen. His affair with Karen Neal has been exposed for years and yet people keep asking questions about that stupid sock. Darlie's Injuries It was the Prosecution's case that on the 6th of June, Darlie stabbed her two boys to death and then went to the sink in the kitchen and slashed her throat and cut her arm over the sink. :/, yea i get why they went to a psychic especially when desperate for info. I just can't buy the idea that Darlie was the one who murdered her kids. Worldwide attn & any further dna testing? Let's be real about this: Darlie did not "sleep" through Devon and Damon being stabbed and her own assault. Twelve days later, on June 18, 1996, Darlie was arrested. I think every last juror saw every last one of those pictures. Brian Pardo isn't actually an attorney. Darlie Routier's murder conviction has been debated in depth since the day she was found guilty 25 years ago. The Routiers had tickets to fly to Pennsylvania and were planning to fly out the following week, on the 14th. She was first tried in the media, then she was tried in the court of public opinion, and, finally, she was tried in a courtroom. Darin had contracted herpes, she did not have herpes. JustinCase976 (author) on December 05, 2019: I'll tell you exactly what I think, and have always thought: it's downright IRRESPONSIBLE to rely upon the fractured memories of a traumatized crime victim whose entire recall of that night is like a piece of Swiss cheese. The transcripts had to be recreated from the original erroneous transcript and an incomplete set of audio tapes by people who were not even in the courtroom during the original trial. The media circled her like sharks, and, eventually, she was sentenced to death-row. Why wouldn't her prints be on it? Doesn't make sense. So why the discrepancies? What if Gorsuch was still awake and happened to see her running outside to plant this sock? John Ramsey, when asked why he obtained legal counsel after his daughter, JonBenet, was murdered. And didnt that famous attorney say after reviewing it all. No one was concerned with trying to preserve a crime scene; the priority was to treat the injured. LOL Fern! Did former Indiana State Trooper David Camm kill his wife and two children? docuseries gives viewers an introduction to European football and a unique look at the working class town of Wrexham, Wales. Well, were you there with him in her presence before the paramedics arrived?